The Detroit Lions are coming home from Germany with a win, but potentially without the services of their top defensive player in Aidan Hutchinson for the rest of the season. In 2024, Hutchinson suffered a left tib/fib fracture. Today, it was his right leg that suffered a significant knee injury.
Hutch hurt himself on a post-sack celebration. Many Lions fans, including me, have been worried about Hutchinson’s jumping celebrations for a while now, which have included Cristiano Ronaldo’s Siuuu...
At least the rest of the game was mostly clean. Here are the injuries I saw along with suspected diagnoses:
🔴Bad news or high concern
🟡Uncertain or moderately concerning
🟢Good news or low concern
🔴Aidan Hutchinson (1Q 9:28) - Suspected right ACL
The video clearly shows the deformity of an anterior tibial shift (lower leg) that pops forward and suddenly pops back. It’s the ACL that limits the anterior shift of the lower leg. One of the exams for the ACL is the Lachman test which pulls the lower leg forward to see if the ACL is still intact.
Here is a picture of Aidan after the game…
The picture doesn’t tell us much, as players can actually walk just fine with a ruptured ACL.
If this is an ACL, the hope is that there is no associated cartilage damage (about 50% have an associated meniscus cartilage tear). If there is no cartilage damage, the prognosis is excellent for a full recovery.
In his postgame press conference, Dan Campbell did not offer any updates or specifics on Hutchinson. Hutch will certainly be getting an MRI to confirm the extent of the injury.
What is the timeline if this is indeed an ACL rupture?
A typical ACL recovery ranges from 9-12 months with 10-11 months being typical. Here are some recent Lions cases:
Jameson Williams returned in 11 months.
Alim McNeill returned in just over 10 months.
Malcolm Rodriguez returned in 12 months after a follow-up knee surgery.
This timeline would put the availability for the start of next season up in the air for Hutchinson. Additionally, players often are not fully back to form in the first year back from an ACL (see Alim). That means this injury would very likely affect the 2027 season. Currently, Hutch is 26 years old and his relatively young age will help his recovery.
🟢Khalil Dorsey (3Q 1:39) - Suspected left calf strain or contusion
Video looked benign, but muscle strains aren’t typically going to be seen on video. The good news is that the knee and ankle looked unaffected.
Trainers were palpating Dorsey’s mid-upper calf area after the play. That’s good news that the Achilles was not an immediate concern.
Update: Dorsey was able to return to play in the 4th quarter so there is no concern going forward here.
Notables
🟢Amon-Ra St. Brown (rib) and Sione Vaki (ankle) were questionable entering the game and played. Both looked good. That makes 10 of 12 (83%) questionables to have played this season.
🟢Andre Cisco just joined the team a few days ago and immediately usurped Keith Abney as the 3rd safety. An unexpected medical finding for Cisco has not had any short-term ramifications.
🟢Jacob Saylors was sporting a neck roll today after missing last game with a neck injury.
🟢DJ Wonnum returned after missing one game with a concussion, and picked up a sack in the 2nd quarter.




