The Lions traded for safety Andre Cisco at the deadline two weeks ago, showing the desire to add a short-term safety rental to the roster. In his first game with the Lions, he usurped rookie Keith Abney, but only got 5 total defensive snaps (8%). In contrast, Brian Branch and Chuck Clark played almost 100% of the snaps.
Cisco’s addition raises some questions about the safety group. Is Cisco there just for depth or is he slated for a bigger role? Does the addition of Cisco say anything about the current safeties and their health?
Brian Branch has played four games since returning from his Achilles rupture.
Kerby Joseph will play his first game of the season tomorrow after missing the last 13 months with a left knee issue.
Chuck Clark was named a captain this past week, which seems to solidify his status.
It will be interesting to see what role Cisco plays for the Lions the rest of the season.
The trade terms had an intriguing twist, as the compensation was renegotiated from a 2028 6th-rounder to a 2029 6th-rounder after unexpected medical findings on the Lions’ physical exam.
For more on how unexpected medical findings can scuttle trades, visit my earlier story about the risks of trading for players…
Below is the complete medical report for Andre Cisco. For the full roster health overview, visit my Lions Injury Tracker.
Medical concern level ranges from 0 (🟢low) to 5 (🟡moderate) to 10 (🔴high).
(Age in parentheses is factored into the concern level. Injury info and ages based on available public information - subject to update. Games played data includes playoffs & courtesy of sports-reference.com.)
Andre Cisco, S (26)
🟡Medical Concern Level: 4/10
Contract: 1-year, $2.5M
2026: 10/10 games played to date. Unexpected findings on physical.
2025: 8 games. Pec surgery ended season.
2024: 16 games
2023: 15 games. Groin, missed 1 game, Hamstring, missed 1 game.
2022: 17 games. Shoulder, missed 2 games.
2021: 17 games
2020 (college): Torn ACL
What unexpected findings on his physical could have caused a renegotiation of trade terms? The findings were not significant enough for the Lions to cancel the trade, but were significant enough for the Lions to reconsider.
Unexpected cartilage damage in a knee joint has affected multiple NFL trades in the past year (Maxx Crosby, Daiyan Henley) and is a possibility for Cisco given his history of a torn ACL. As seen with Aidan Hutchinson, associated meniscus damage can occur with an ACL. This would be something that isn’t much of a concern on a 1-year deal, but could become a problem down the road.
Other possibilities include a residual issue with his shoulder injury from 2022. His 2023 “groin” can sometimes actually be a more-concerning core muscle or hip issue, but he’s played three seasons since.
Last year’s pec surgery should have minimal residuals. However, there were some reports that it was actually a shoulder surgery, which could be more worrisome if it involved the joint.
Cisco has been mostly reliable so far in the NFL. In his 6-year career, he’s compiled 8 interceptions, 4 forced fumbles, 26 pass defenses, and 2.5 sacks.
If the Lions are viewing Cisco as a short-term rental, then the unexpected medical findings may not be of relevance. If the Lions are hoping to re-sign Cisco, then the unexpected medical findings could become a factor.
Cisco’s age of 26 is excellent and makes him a potential long-term member of the team if the Lions choose to re-sign or extend him.

